A white church with blue shutters and a sign reading "St. Columba's Anglican/Catholic Church".

Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Tarpum Bay, South Eleuthera

  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation
  • Treat yourself

    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Tarpum Bay 4 Star Hotels

Our top choices for Tarpum Bay 4-star hotels

French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection

French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
9.6 out of 10, Exceptional, (31 reviews)
"It was definitely a wonderful retreat with lots of privacy and awesome staff. Great amenities, beautifully maintained grounds and delicious meals!!!"
United States
Juan
The price is 17.726.033 ₫
22.894.449 ₫ total
includes taxes & fees
5 Aug - 6 Aug
French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection

Laughing Bird Suites

Laughing Bird Suites
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
9.8 out of 10, Exceptional, (14 reviews)
"Beautiful location and very friendly staff. "
United States
Nicole
The price is 5.796.945 ₫
8.065.904 ₫ total
includes taxes & fees
27 Jul - 28 Jul
Laughing Bird Suites

Sky Beach Club

Sky Beach Club
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
8.6 out of 10, Excellent, (107 reviews)
"It is a good size property with a low density of villas. Mine was near the pool and restaurant area, but I think they’re only three villas in a row. The beach is quite nearby is large and largely empty. It seems to be a perfect couples getaway spot. It’s also well placed near the center of the island to allow travel both north and south within an an hour and a half to two hours each way. They do a new job, maintaining the place and provide a memorable vacation venue."
United States
Richard
Sky Beach Club

Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina

Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina
4.0 star property
Freetown
8.8 out of 10, Excellent, (23 reviews)
"Everything about this resort was beautiful! I am so happy we decided to book this wonderful place! it has truly been a remarkable experience! We can't wait to return! "
United States
Tiffany
The price is 11.363.852 ₫
13.125.249 ₫ total
includes taxes & fees
3 Aug - 4 Aug
Cape Eleuthera Resort & Marina

The Potlatch Club

The Potlatch Club
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
The Potlatch Club

Caribbean Retreat: Private Villa With Panoramic Ocean Views

Caribbean Retreat: Private Villa With Panoramic Ocean Views
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Caribbean Retreat: Private Villa With Panoramic Ocean Views

Seven Palms

Seven Palms
4.0 star property
North Palmetto Point
Seven Palms

Sandy Hill Beach House by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Sandy Hill Beach House by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Sandy Hill Beach House by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Squires Estate

Squires Estate
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
9.0 out of 10, Wonderful, (11 reviews)
"The hotel was perfect, the staff were warm, kind and helpful. The cottage we stayed in had a mini refrigerator and coffee maker. There is a lovely pool with deck chairs overlooking the beautiful Harbour and sunset. We will definitely be returning! Eleuthera is just a treasure!"
United States
michelle
Squires Estate

Island Oasis: Beachfront Retreat With Infinity Pool

Island Oasis: Beachfront Retreat With Infinity Pool
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Island Oasis: Beachfront Retreat With Infinity Pool

Newly Built Luxury Villa On The Beach

Newly Built Luxury Villa On The Beach
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Newly Built Luxury Villa On The Beach

Flipper'S Haven: Tropical Retreat

Flipper'S Haven: Tropical Retreat
4.0 star property
North Palmetto Point
Flipper'S Haven: Tropical Retreat

Shangri-La Serenity: Beach Villa With Views

Shangri-La Serenity: Beach Villa With Views
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Shangri-La Serenity: Beach Villa With Views

Cocodimama by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Cocodimama by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Cocodimama by Eleuthera Vacation Rentals

Caribbean Dream: Secluded Villa With Private Beachfront

Caribbean Dream: Secluded Villa With Private Beachfront
4.0 star property
Double Bay
Caribbean Dream: Secluded Villa With Private Beachfront

Cotton Bay Oasis: Grand Estate On Private Acres

Cotton Bay Oasis: Grand Estate On Private Acres
4.0 star property
Greencastle
Cotton Bay Oasis: Grand Estate On Private Acres

Pink Sand Perfection: Private Cozy Cottage

Pink Sand Perfection: Private Cozy Cottage
4.0 star property
North Palmetto Point
Pink Sand Perfection: Private Cozy Cottage

Caribbean Cliffside: Private Waterfront Retreat

Caribbean Cliffside: Private Waterfront Retreat
4.0 star property
North Palmetto Point
Caribbean Cliffside: Private Waterfront Retreat

Coastal Haven: Charming Beachfront Cottage With Pool

Coastal Haven: Charming Beachfront Cottage With Pool
4.0 star property
Governor's Harbour
Coastal Haven: Charming Beachfront Cottage With Pool

Banks Road Bliss: Luxury Estate With Pool

Banks Road Bliss: Luxury Estate With Pool
4.0 star property
South Palmetto Point
Banks Road Bliss: Luxury Estate With Pool
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Learn more about Tarpum Bay

Colourful fishing boats line the harbour where locals sell their fresh catch at the waterfront dock each morning. Explore nearby pink sand beaches or join locals at the Friday fish fry for authentic Bahamian flavours and live music.

A white church with blue shutters and a sign reading "St. Columba's Anglican/Catholic Church".

Top Tarpum Bay Hotel Reviews