Compare and book 3 Star hotels in Pitcher, New York

"It was really nice to be greeted with wine, cheese, and crackers! The owners were nice and responsive, and the location on the lake is beautiful. But the house felt like it was slanting into the lake, there ceilings were cracked and damaged, and water in the kitchen smelled strongly of sulfur. We lost power, which was not surprising, but I was surprised the owners were not prepared. No candles or flashlights, except a citronella candle."

"Our family stayed here to attend a college graduation nearby. The lake view and vibe were both amazing and peaceful. We were greeted by our hosts, they were very friendly and helpful. The cottage had everything , my sons enjoyed the canoe and paddle boards provided too. The 2nd night, the entire area lost power, we lost water too, that put a damper on the trip.."

"The rooms are spotless, soft carpets & side tables with charging lamps! Great amenities, all clean linen & soaps provided in all bathrooms. Well renovated & everything worked perfectly. Big TV in the living room & cozy living room couch set! Some big beds with multiple pillows & a fan. Very comfortable stay. "