Compare and book 3 Star hotels in Pitcher, New York

"Peaceful and quiet but wifi is spotty. Overall, the best place we have ever stayed over our 20 years of military overnights."

"A fantastic experience all around great communication through texting and emails. Let me know all the details. Everything was very clean. You felt like you were staying at a friend’s house. We will definitely come back again."

"The property is amazing! Clean, well kept! Would definitely stay again!"

"It was really nice to be greeted with wine, cheese, and crackers! The owners were nice and responsive, and the location on the lake is beautiful. But the house felt like it was slanting into the lake, there ceilings were cracked and damaged, and water in the kitchen smelled strongly of sulfur. We lost power, which was not surprising, but I was surprised the owners were not prepared. No candles or flashlights, except a citronella candle."

"The property we stayed at was so clean and homey! The owner is top notch to deal with. If i come to that area again, i know where i want to go back!"

"They supposedly didn’t know we were coming, there was a mouse in the toilet, the floors had not been swept, they had a bunch of food and in the freezer and fridge, liquor had been out, no wifi or service, the bed sheets were dirty, no curtains on any of the windows, the doors and ALL windows were unlocked when we got there but the didn’t know we were coming? "