Compare and book 4 Star hotels in Pine Island, New York

"We had a very lovely time here. Food was incredible."

"Lovely property, owner and food! A gem!"

"The house is well located and Eileen was a great host."

"Nice area I had previously never seen. We walked down to the hotel one morning for breakfast, and the condo was a short drive from Wawayanda State Park, where I had an event. Nice condo - comfortable and clean. Instructions ahead of time were clear and given with ample notice."

"I had a wonderful stay at this property ! The place was absolutely beautiful—cozy, well-decorated, and surrounded by peaceful nature. Everything was spotless and clearly well taken care of, which made it easy to relax and enjoy our time there. The owner was incredibly prompt and attentive, responding quickly to any questions and making sure we had everything we needed. You can really tell they care about their guests’ experience. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to...

"Location was so close to have lunch during skiing for the kids to have a break right off the slope. The condo was so clean and inviting. Kids loved having their basement area to themselves. I would do this again"

"Lovely, peaceful home away from home. "

"Amazing rental property, amazing place to spend quality time with your loves ones from young to adult everybody felt welcome to the house with a lot to do, very very good host very responsive to messages. Will be going back for sure!!!!!!!!"