Independent, Holbrook, New York

"The hotel is a perfect stay, staff is overwhelmingly friendly, and the food service is great. "

"My girlfriend and I had an absolutely wonderful time visiting Cherry Grove/Fire Island for the first time, and the Grove Hotel was a big reason why. Our room was immaculate, it appeared to have been recently renovated/updated, with plenty of room for 2 and a nice mini-balcony for viewing the wildlife at the pool and the bar. 😎 Cherry Grove is a tiny hamlet, so location can't be a real issue no matter where you stay, but the hotel is literally steps away from the clubs, restaurants, shops,...

"Great location. "

"Had a wonderful 6 night stay here and like all the other reviews it was wonderful. Clean, pretty interior , staff was kind and accommodating. Front desk was always sweet and happy to help."

"☺️"

"This proetty is very quiet and beautiful. Rooms are extremely clean. Property is very beautiful. I will absolutely go back. "

"Nice & affordable! "

"The manager was SO nice. You can tell that he truly cares. We checked in very late and he still made an effort to accommodate us and was very caring. "