Compare and book 3 Star hotels in College Hill Historic District, Ithaca

"Room was clean, everything as advertised. Staff polite."

"Great place to stay. Been here 2x and highly recommended "

"Staff is friendly and property has very interesting history"

"This was a peaceful getaway. The property is beautiful and well maintained. The staff were very friendly and welcoming. I would return again."

"We had a terrific stay at Inn On Columbia! Kenn and Madeline are lovely hosts. Breakfast was 10/10 as well! "

"What a great property "

"Beautiful bed and breakfast and loved the room we stayed in service was great "

"Rented the place for two days trip with 4 other friends. It’s was very nice to be there. Downstairs bedroom is dirty the carpet needs to be changed and also the windows are dirty. Overall excellent job though out the house we were very comfortable. I will definitely recommend it. "

"A gem on a quiet lake. Near vineyards and countless waterfalls."

"We had a fabulous time at this property. Jeff, the host, was close by if we had a question (or to share some breakfast with him!). The home was comfortable, with all the amenities we needed. It was a great location for what we had planned.....hiking waterfalls in the area. It was close to grocery stores in Ithaca, and shopping too. When, and if, we are back in the area, we will definitely book again with Jeff!! Thank you Jeff!!! "