Fire Island Holiday Rentals, New York: Private House Rentals

A lighthouse, a red-roofed building, and a wooden structure near a coastal area.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Go beyond your typical stay in Fire Island

Pet friendly

Apartment

Pool

Spa

Hot tub

Condo

Cottage

Family friendly

Waterpark

Check prices for these dates

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Our top choices for Fire Island hotels

A modern hotel room with a large bed, a seating area with a bench, a small table, and a chair.

A modern bedroom with a large bed, a blue headboard, a bedside table, a chair, and a window with blinds.

A modern bathroom with a white sink, toilet, and glass shower enclosure.

A rectangular pool with a wooden deck, lounge chairs, and a lifeguard stand.

1. Grove Hotel

Sayville

Robert

3.475.336 ₫

3.970.573 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

19 Oct - 20 Oct

A bedroom with a bed, a ceiling fan, and large windows.

A garden with a stone pathway leading through lush greenery and bamboo.

A gym with a bench, dumbbells, a squat rack, and a fan.

A swimming pool with lounge chairs and umbrellas, surrounded by greenery.

2. The Pines Men-Only Stay

Sayville

"The property is beautifully appointed and most importantly it is very welcoming—André clearly wants guests to feel at home. The place has a quiet, friendly vibe where people go to relax and read and chat and enjoy the beach and the Pines & Cherry Grove Village. The pool is the perfect place to read or chat. André does a great job at anticipating guests’ needs—from universal charging cords to ear plugs and lens wipes—he has thought of it all."

Matthew

10.449.331 ₫

13.714.902 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

15 Oct - 16 Oct

An outdoor bar area with seating and a fire feature, surrounded by a building with multiple floors and large windows.

A modern lounge area with seating arrangements, a bar, and a large window providing natural light.

A Courtyard Marriott hotel with a covered outdoor seating area, a clear entrance, and a parking lot.

A hotel room with two beds, a desk, a chair, a large window with curtains, and a colorful wall mural.

3. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Central Islip

Amanda

3.939.232 ₫

4.500.572 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

19 Oct - 20 Oct

An indoor swimming pool with sunlit areas, lounge chairs, and potted plants.

A reception area with a dark wood reception desk, two laptops, a vase with white flowers, and a glass table.

A spacious dining area with high ceilings, large windows, and a zebra-striped carpet. Tables are neatly arranged with chairs, and the room is well-lit with ceiling lights.

A hallway with a high ceiling, large windows, and a patterned carpet.

4. Hyatt Regency Long Island

Hauppauge

Leonardo

3.722.833 ₫

4.253.337 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

18 Oct - 19 Oct

A hotel with a prominent sign, a covered entrance, and a car parked in front.

A hotel reception area with a wooden reception desk, a framed artwork above the counter, and a potted plant on the counter.

A spacious restaurant with multiple dining tables and chairs, a kitchen area, and a large window.

A hotel lobby with a reception desk, seating area with armchairs and sofas, patterned carpet, and ambient lighting.

5. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

Bohemia

darrell

2.178.288 ₫

2.488.694 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

An outdoor patio area with a stone fire pit surrounded by sofas and chairs, string lights overhead, and a view of a multi-story building in the background.

A large indoor swimming pool with clear blue water, surrounded by lounge chairs and tables, with a high ceiling and large windows.

A spacious lobby with a stone pillar, a flat-screen TV, comfortable seating, and large windows offering a view of the outdoors.

6. Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Central Islip

Meghan

3.852.717 ₫

4.401.729 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

29 Oct - 30 Oct

A modern building entrance with a bench, potted plants, and a blue mat leading to a reception area.

A hotel room with a large bed, a desk with a chair, a desk lamp, and a bedside table with a phone.

A modern hotel room with a blue sofa, a wooden desk, a chair, a lamp, and a television.

A spacious lobby with a reception desk, seating area, and a staircase leading to upper floors.

7. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

Hauppauge

Alberto

3.378.928 ₫

3.860.447 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

18 Oct - 19 Oct

A couple in white bathrobes holding champagne glasses in a hotel room with a large window and a door in the background.

A spacious atrium with high ceilings, a glass ceiling, and multiple levels of balconies.

A spacious atrium with high ceilings, large windows, and a modern architectural design.

A bar area with a hexagonal shelving unit displaying bottles, a flat-screen TV, and bar stools.

8. Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult Only

Islandia

WILLIAM

3.547.641 ₫

4.053.262 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

18 Oct - 19 Oct

An indoor swimming pool with clear glass walls, a tiled floor, and a few chairs near the windows.

A modern hotel lobby with a 'welcome' sign, comfortable seating areas, and a flat-screen TV mounted on the wall.

A modern office space with a large flat-screen TV, a desk with a chair, a microwave, and a small plant.

A hotel room with a large bed, a desk with a computer, a flat-screen TV, and a window with a view of greenery.

9. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

Islandia

Jeronda

2.718.070 ₫

3.105.394 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A backyard with a dense lavender plant, wooden chairs, and a wooden deck.

A backyard with a swimming pool, a patio with chairs and a table, and a covered area with umbrellas.

A bar area with wooden furniture, a piano, and a group of people.

10. Come As You Are Inn

Sayville

luiz claudio

5.831.100 ₫

6.662.033 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

15 Oct - 16 Oct

An indoor swimming pool with clear water, surrounded by a glass enclosure with a view of the outdoors.

A modern hotel reception area with a wooden reception desk, a geometric wall design, and a spacious atrium with balconies and plants.

A modern hotel room with a large bed, a TV, a seating area, and a chandelier.

11. Marriott Melville Long Island

Melville

Adrian

6.193.924 ₫

7.076.882 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

15 Oct - 16 Oct

A spacious living room with a fireplace, large windows, and a modern chandelier.

An outdoor patio area with brick flooring, round tables, chairs, and large umbrellas.

A modern kitchen with a bar area, marble countertops, and dark wooden cabinets.

A store named 'The Shop' with a variety of chilled beverages, snacks, and dairy products.

12. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma

Elizabeth

3.282.261 ₫

3.749.984 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A large, multi-story hotel with a prominent tower and a covered entrance.

A bar area with a long counter, bar stools, a menu board, and a variety of bottles and glasses.

A modern hotel lobby with a sectional sofa, dining area, and a bar.

A hotel room with a bed, a sofa, a small table, a chair, a kitchenette, and a large window with curtains.

13. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma

Kristen

4.120.644 ₫

4.708.160 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

18 Oct - 19 Oct

A well-organized snack and beverage section with shelves stocked with various products, a refrigerated display, and a small table with snacks.

A modern reception area with a wooden desk, two computer monitors, a sofa, and a decorative shelf with various items.

A modern office space with two desks, each with a computer monitor, keyboard, and a vase of flowers.

A modern hotel lobby with a reception desk, directional signs, a dining area with chairs, a sofa, and a large framed artwork on the wall.

14. Holiday Inn Long Island-Islip Arpt East by IHG

Holtsville

Mohammad

2.619.132 ₫

2.992.553 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

25 Oct - 26 Oct

A café named 'CAFE PRONTO' with a counter and seating area.

A spacious lobby with a checkered floor, red and beige seating areas, a bar with a counter, and a conference room with red chairs and a desk.

A spacious restaurant with multiple dining areas, wooden furniture, and a high ceiling with exposed beams.

A swimming pool with a tiled edge, benches, and lounge chairs.

15. Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Hauppauge

Franck

3.172.118 ₫

3.624.145 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A covered wooden deck with white railings, blue doors, and hanging flower arrangements.

A wooden dock with wicker chairs and a blue umbrella, overlooking a marina with boats and palm trees.

A living room with a patterned sofa set, a glass coffee table, and a decorative chandelier.

A marina with boats docked, a pier with blue umbrellas and white chairs, and a flagpole with flags.

16. Danfords Hotel and Marina

Port Jefferson

Esther

4.488.178 ₫

6.148.174 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

4 Nov - 5 Nov

A large indoor swimming pool with a tiled floor, lounge chairs, and a lifeguard stand.

A sign for Stony Brook State University of New York surrounded by greenery and flowers.

A modern hotel lobby with a central coffee bar, seating areas, and a flat-screen TV mounted on the wall.

17. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG

Centereach

Mirna

3.602.324 ₫

4.115.720 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

26 Oct - 27 Oct

An indoor swimming pool with clear blue water, surrounded by lounge chairs and tables.

A hotel entrance with a flag, a covered walkway, and a sign for Homewood Suites Hilton.

A courtyard with outdoor seating, a barbecue grill, and a pool table.

A modern kitchen with a central island, glass display case, and dark wood cabinets.

18. Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma

Ronkonkoma

Nicole

4.041.082 ₫

4.616.938 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A modern kitchen with a breakfast bar, waffle station, and various food items displayed.

A hotel room with a desk, chair, television, and a small table with a lamp.

A hotel room with a bed, a desk with a flat-screen TV, a chair, a large window with curtains, and a wall-mounted mirror.

An indoor swimming pool with clear depth markers, a lifeguard chair, and a seating area with tables and chairs.

19. Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack

Commack

Daniel

3.282.261 ₫

3.749.984 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

1 Nov - 2 Nov

A swimming pool with a tiled deck, surrounded by windows and chairs.

An outdoor patio with a grill, dining table, chairs, and a basketball hoop.

A modern kitchen with grey cabinets, a black countertop, and a wooden floor.

A compact kitchen with wooden cabinets, a stainless steel refrigerator, a microwave, and a coffee maker.

20. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville

Holtsville

Carly

3.502.547 ₫

4.001.660 ₫ total

includes taxes & fees

18 Oct - 19 Oct

View all properties

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Stay near popular Fire Island attractions

A lighthouse with a red roof, a wooden fence, and sand dunes in the foreground.

Fire Island Lighthouse

8.6/10 (20 reviews)

This historic 168-foot beacon stands as a proud symbol of Long Island's maritime heritage. Climb 182 steps to the top for breathtaking 360-degree views of the Atlantic seascape.

See properties

A lighthouse with a black and white tower next to a stone building with a red roof.

Robert Moses Water Tower

8.0/10 (11 reviews)

This Art Deco tower, modelled on Venice's St. Mark's campanile, stands as Jones Beach's iconic 200-foot sentinel. Admire its elegant architecture while exploring the surrounding park's ocean views and scenic boardwalk.

See properties

Sunken Forest

8.0/10 (7 reviews)

This rare maritime holly forest grows behind protective dunes, creating the illusion it's sunken below sea level. Stroll the 1.5-mile boardwalk through ancient trees before emerging onto pristine Atlantic beaches.

See properties

Ocean Beach

9.0/10 (57 reviews)

Explore Fire Island's largest village, where car-free streets lead to boutique shops and pristine beaches. Savour fresh seafood at waterfront restaurants or join summer art shows in this laid-back coastal haven.

See properties

Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre

8.0/10 (3 reviews)

America's oldest continuously operating LGBTQ+ theatre has been a cultural hub in Cherry Grove since the mid-20th century. Summer visitors can enjoy vibrant performances celebrating queer history in this historic venue.

See properties

TWA Flight 800 International Memorial

8.0/10 (36 reviews)

This oceanfront memorial honours 230 lives lost in the 1996 TWA Flight 800 tragedy with a granite monument and symbolic seagulls. Visit at sunset when the Atlantic views create a moving atmosphere for reflection.

See properties

Carrington House

10.0/10 (1 review)

This historic 1912 bungalow was where Truman Capote wrote "Breakfast at Tiffany's" while hosted by Frank Carrington. Tours reveal its significance as a cultural hub for artists and the LGBTQ+ community.

See properties

Learn more about Fire Island

Pristine beaches and car-free boardwalks await on this barrier island, where you can bike between quaint villages and Fire Island Lighthouse. Catch a water taxi to explore secluded spots, or join locals for sunset cocktails at bayside restaurants in Ocean Beach.

See all hotels in Fire Island

A lighthouse with a black and white tower, a red-roofed building, and tall grasses in the foreground.

Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews

Hotels in Fire Island with star rating

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

More ways to book

Book Hotels in Fire Island on Expedia.com

Find hotels in Fire Island, NY

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Go beyond your typical stay in Fire Island

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Star rating

Guest rating

Our top choices for Fire Island hotels

1. Grove Hotel

2. The Pines Men-Only Stay

3. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

4. Hyatt Regency Long Island

5. La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport

6. Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

7. Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

8. Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult Only

9. Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia

10. Come As You Are Inn

11. Marriott Melville Long Island

12. Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

13. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport

14. Holiday Inn Long Island-Islip Arpt East by IHG

15. Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

16. Danfords Hotel and Marina

17. Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook by IHG

18. Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma

19. Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack

20. Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville

Stay near popular Fire Island attractions

Fire Island Lighthouse

Robert Moses Water Tower

Sunken Forest

Ocean Beach

Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre

TWA Flight 800 International Memorial

Carrington House

Learn more about Fire Island

Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews

Hotels in Fire Island with star rating

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Go further with the Expedia app