Compare and book 2 Star hotels in Sidney Center, New York

"Stayed 3 nights in April 2026. The owner's were very accommodating to our late night arrival and throughout our stay. Hotel was easy to find. Stayed in a room with 3 beds. Plenty of room for all our stuff and ourselves, extremely clean and the beds are so comfortable. Would highly recommend and definitely stay here anytime in the area. This hotel even still cleans your room daily! Have not seen that at any hotel since Covid. "

"We had a nice two night stay. The property, overlooking the lake, is beautiful. Charming reception area and dining room/ restaurant. The employees were pleasant. Breakfast was delicious. Taking away a star because both nights we had someone traipsing up and down all night in the room above ours. The floors are extremely creaky (understandable given the age of the building) so this meant we were disturbed all night. The reception is not manned at night and we didn't want to call the managerI guess if we went back we could request a top floor room but you can hear people walking around in the hallway outside as well. There was also a large stain on the carpet and sofa that really should be cleaned or otherwise dealt with. Overall a good stay though. "