Search Hotels Near Sagamore Hill National Historic Site, Oyster Bay

"The Good: The sheets and towels were always fresh & clean, shower & hot water good. Parking excellent. Heat & A/C unit excellent. The Bad: This place is for anyone who only needs a shower and a bed. All 4 pillows on the bed rate the worst I have ever had around the entire world. I have no sense of smell, and I could smell stuff that I could not identify. No elevator which I was told up front so you have to climb a straight set of steps. I CANNOT BELIEVE THIS HOTEL COULDN'T AFFORD TO PUT OUT SOME COFFEE IN THE LOBBY OR THE "NOT USED, FORMER" BREAKFAST AREA. There is no staff other than a person sitting behind a window. The Ugly: Our room was a complete mismatch of furnishings. The entire building (including our room) is very old looking and worn out. Our bathroom door would not close and has patched holes in it. The owner need not respond to me. I think you should be ashamed at how cheap and rundown this place is. Jeffrey Lynn & Wife 04/22/2026"

"The rooms need a little updating/attention. Stay was comfortable "

"PLEASE DO NOT STAY HERE IF YOU DO NOT ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO! It is gross and engulfed in mold. We were trying to save money but this place it NOT worth the savings. The housekeeping did the best they could, but the building and furniture are complete TRASH. The place looks like it should be condemned and the furniture looks like it was salvaged from the dump. I am not exaggerating. We needed a last-minute reservation for at least 4 consecutive nights when we received news of a relative's death. The airfare and missed work were already going to be a large financial burden, so we tried to save money on the hotel. We thought bringing our own linens and towels would be enough, but we know better now not to trust this sort of place ever again. The shower had good pressure and the hot water didn't run out, and thank goodness for that, because the only reason we stayed was because we were able to purchase bleach at the grocery store right across the street. What makes all of this incredibly surprising is that this is listed through Expedia. I am shocked they would allow themselves to be affiliated with such a property. It really makes me reconsider whether I can ever trust Expedia again. There was no ironing board, but even if there was, it would have been too filthy to use. There was no hairdryer. There was only one small lamp in a large, dark and dank room. The keys didn't work at least half the time but the AC and heat did, so we were lucky in that regard."

"Everything was great. The bed is firm. Breakfast was good."

"While the property was very clean, the ROI was atrocious. I believe I paid $940 for two nights. There was no restaurant, there was no bar at the property. I heard people walking in the room above me with the floor board/ceiling squecking. The breakfast "buffet" was a joke. Finally, insult to injury was the fact that we also had to pay $20/night for the valet parking as the property also did not include self parking. The property was clean w/out a doubt. The rooms up to date. However, the price was in no relation to the amenities. Obviously, I do no mind paying otherwise I would not have booked but I should have better researched what I was getting in return. I have stayed at 5 star properties for this price. Truly shocked that they are able to charge these prices - then again that is on me for not doing a better job researching what I was getting into."

"Food at the Bistro was delicious. The staff there were very nice. Evan at check in, was personable and efficient. The negatives were; no windows in the rooms and the Air conditioner in my room did not work. Maintenance came and made adjustments but did not fix anything. I slept in a warm room for two nights."

"yes"

"Great stay!"

"Good enough for a night stay"