Independent, Mayville, New York

"What a surprise we found at the Athenaeum, a grand hotel from the 19th century, on beautiful Lake Chatauqua. On arrival, we found ourselves entering a gated community spread along the lake shore, with wonderful 19th and 20th century summer homes, within walking distance of the hotel. The entry to the hotel opens into a large traditional open lobby where the front desk sits opposite a wide staircase to the second and third floors, alongside a comfortable bar area where one can order food and...

"Room was very clean and nice. Hotel staff very friendly. "

"Clean, quiet motel with personable innkeeper. "

"Beautiful rooms in a historical hotel. Bar area and dining room very nice and good prices."

"Was great...real relaxing...and hosting was great...they were more then willing to help with all..AAA+++"

"Check in was easy, the room was comfortable and clean and convenient to town! Would definitely stay again. "

"Very clean! "

"When I arrived at the Butler House, the owner (MK) informed me that it was actually closed for renovations. Expedia had been repeatedly informed of this but continued, nonetheless, to book reservations for guests! MK was very apologetic and offered me accommodation in the camper beside the house. It looked to be very comfortable and roomy, and had a relatively large fridge, so I accepted. Never regretted the decision. It was so quiet and cool in the evenings that I slept very soundly, and the...